The KPI Series Metrics for Successful Lead Generation

KPI Metrics for Successful Lead Generation6 min read

If you are a business that drives leads, I think you’ll agree that you can’t measure success without measuring the right Key Performance Indicators (KPIs).

Well, it turns out, you can drive success at a higher rate through proper measurements of the right metrics. It’s not as difficult as you may expect and with your new-found insights, you might be able to hit the ground running with your marketing efforts, instead of always lagging behind.

In today’s insights report, I’m going to walk you through what metrics are most effective to measure lead generation marketing.

So, let’s get to it…

As a lead generation business, you have many things to be focusing your time and efforts on, and measurement, not surprisingly should be one of them. Measuring your marketing efforts can assist with helping you generate more. You may be wondering how I can make a bold statement like that? Well, I’ll tell you why. Because when you are focused on the right things, instead of focusing on everything, you can see much more clearly.

Lead Generation Metrics You Should Measure

Metric #1: Conversions and Goal Completions

This one may be the most obvious, but measuring conversions and goal completions should be top of your list. You need to fully understand what you are getting from your digital marketing efforts to be able to make smart decisions on where to continue to invest.  

Let’s take this concept one step further. Let’s take a moment to talk about the purchase funnel.

Because the purchase funnel is not as straight and direct as it used to be, and decisions are happening across multiple channels, it’s important to look beyond each channel when considering where your leads are coming from. No longer is last-click attribution the only option. If you are using a system such as Google Analytics, you can more granularly measure your conversions across channels by choosing an attribution model. There are many different attribution models including time decay, linear, position-based and so on. We talk more about attribution models in another post and you can read more about it here – Conversion Attribution Model.

There are two lessons in this first tip:

  1. Be sure to look beyond last-click attribution for a higher understanding of what digital marketing channels are assisting with each conversion.
  2. Two, don’t overlook the fact that not all your conversions are coming from a single channel.

Many times direct conversions can’t be measured because of the complexity of the purchase funnel. People are constantly weaving in and out of different marketing channels and devices. It’s hard to 100% know each lead generation’s path to purchase. Leads, that we think are driven directly, may have, in fact, come from other previous forms of digital marketing efforts.  This is why it’s important not to overlook the fact that all your digital marketing efforts matter. 

Metric #2: Conversion Rate

Next up is Conversion Rate. The conversion rate is the equation of clicks divided by conversions. The conversion rate key performance indicator is a great way to understand the percentage of possible leads compared to how leads are actually converted. A higher conversion rate is always better, but it’s important to see how conversion rates trend over time. If your leads are not converting according to your business needs, you’ll be relieved to know this is a metric you have the power to change.

Before I describe how to increase your business’ conversion rates, it’s important to also understand how lead generations and conversions vary depending on the industry. The types of campaigns you are running for your business will also make a huge difference in how many leads you are able to generate.

Conversion Rate by Industry


Optimizing To Increase Conversion Rates

The conversion rate is one of those metrics, along with Click-Through Rates (but that metric is for another Series), that you do have a small level of control over. You’re probably wondering, how? I’m going to tell you because it’s easy and many marketers don’t spend enough time or energy on it. I’m talking about testing.

If your conversion rate is not as high as you’d like, you’ve got to test.

Testing can be as simple as comparing 2 landing pages against each other. Use two different variants to see if one generates a higher rate of conversion. Changing your offer or ‘pull’ or adjusting the language on your landing pages will make your marketing efforts more enticing to your target audience.

Once you determine which variant drives greater success, you can swap out the underperforming item with a new variation to see how that performs against the original. Keep using this same process to continue to drive a greater conversion rate.

Metric #3: Cost Per Lead

When we’re talking about digital marketing, it always circles back to cost. As a lead generation business, it takes time and money to generate leads. If you want to be sure your marketing efforts are driving a solid return on your investment, cost per lead is an important key performance metric. Cost per lead is the calculation of total cost divided by the total number of leads.

When setting up your cost per lead numbers, be sure to be realistic. We often see lead generation companies pulling numbers out of thin air.

Really, a $30 cost per lead when your services cost $30,000? You may be more comfortable with investing more in generating good, quality leads when you take into consideration your close rate of those leads. Let’s take this concept one step further. Imagine your business operates with a $10,000 monthly marketing budget, you’ve generated 400 site visitors (if your CPC was $25) and you have a conservative 3% conversion rate. That will be 14 leads. Your close rate on those leads is 25%. You’ve just generated roughly 3 new clients. Your cost per lead just went up to over $2,857.

Now, under normal circumstances, you’d probably be flipping your lid, right? But, you’re smart and you realized that those 3 clients just drove $90,000 in revenue. That cost per lead isn’t so terrible now, is it?

Our final metric on the list today; Customer lifetime value.

Metric #4: Customer Lifetime Value

More often than not, we make the mistake of only measuring the value of a lead once. Often times, we forget that those leads will generate more value over time. Maybe the lifetime value of a specific lead will come in the form of a return customer, or future upgrade of services, a monthly membership, or a cross-sell of other services. So keep the Customer Lifetime Value metric in the back of your mind when looking at your return on investment.

I hope you’ve gained some valuable insight into which metrics you, as a lead generation business, should be reporting on and measuring. Follow the Pepper Gang blog for more updates, further insights into metrics, and recommendations for your brand.



Eligibility: The Pepper Gang Free Website Giveaway (or “Giveaway”) is open only to those who submit a video on and who are at least 18 years of age as of the date of entry. The giveaway is only open to legal residents of the New England region of the United States of America (Maine, Vermont, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut and Rhode Island) and is void where prohibited by law. Employees of Pepper Gang, their respective affiliates, subsidiaries, advertising and promotion agencies, suppliers and their immediate family members and/or those living in the same household of each are not eligible to participate in the giveaway. The giveaway is subject to all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations. 

Agreement to Rules: By participating, you agree to be fully unconditionally bound by these Rules, and you represent and warrant that you meet the eligibility requirements set forth herein. In addition, you agree to accept the decisions of Pepper Gang, as final and binding as it relates to the content. The giveaway is subject to all applicable federal, state and local laws.

Giveaway Period: Entries will be accepted online starting on 09/01/2021 and ending 10/01/2021. All online entries must be received by 10/01/2021 at 11:59PM EST.

How to Enter: The giveaway must be entered by submitting an entry using the online form provided on the website. The entry must fulfill all giveaway requirements, as specified, to be eligible to win the free website. Entries that are not complete or do not adhere to the rules or specifications may be disqualified at the sole discretion of Pepper Gang. You may enter only once and you must fill in the information requested. You may not enter more times than indicated by using multiple email addresses, identities or devices in an attempt to circumvent the rules. If you use fraudulent methods or otherwise attempt to circumvent the rules your submission may be removed from eligibility at the sole discretion of Pepper Gang.

Prize: Winners will receive one free, 5 page website, one year of website hosting for free, free logo creation, free video content or photoshoot, and a free, non-premium domain name valued at over $20,000. No cash or other prize substitution permitted except at Pepper Gang’s discretion. The prize is non-transferable. Any and all prize related expenses, including without limitation any and all federal, state, and/or local taxes shall be the sole responsibility of Pepper Gang. No substitution of prize or transfer/assignment of prize to others or request for the cash equivalent by winners is permitted. Acceptance of prize constitutes permission for Pepper Gang to use the winner’s name, likeness, and entry for purposes of advertising and trade without further compensation, unless prohibited by law.

Winner selection and notification: Pepper Gang will select three top finalists that we feel should be in the running for the winning of the free website. Pepper Gang will have these three finalists available to be voted on by 10/01/2021. The public will have one week to vote on which finalist should win. Whoever amounts to the greatest number of votes will win. Winners will be notified via email to the email address they entered the giveaway within five (5) days following the winner selection. Pepper Gang shall have no liability for a winner’s failure to receive notices due to winners’ spam, junk e-mail or other security settings or for winners’ provision of incorrect or otherwise non-functioning contact information. If the selected winner cannot be contacted, is ineligible, fails to claim the prize within 3 days from the time award notification was sent, or fails to timely return a completed and executed declaration and releases as required, prize may be forfeited and an alternate winner selected. 

The receipt by the winner of the prize offered in this giveaway is conditioned upon compliance with any and all federal and state laws and regulations. ANY VIOLATION OF THESE OFFICIAL RULES BY ANY WINNER (AT PEPPER GANG’S SOLE DISCRETION) WILL RESULT IN SUCH WINNER’S DISQUALIFICATION AS WINNER OF THE GIVEAWAY AND ALL PRIVILEGES AS WINNER WILL BE IMMEDIATELY TERMINATED.

Rights Granted by you: By entering this content you understand that Pepper Gang, anyone acting on behalf of Pepper Gang, or its respective licensees, successors and assigns will have the right, where permitted by law, without any further notice, review or consent to print, publish, broadcast, distribute, and use, worldwide in any media now known or hereafter in perpetuity and throughout the World, your entry, including, without limitation, the entry and winner’s name, portrait, picture, voice, likeness, image or statements about the giveaway, and biographical information as news, publicity or information and for trade, advertising, public relations and promotional purposes without any further compensation.

Terms: Pepper Gang reserves the right, in its sole discretion to cancel, terminate, modify or suspend the giveaway should (in its sole discretion) a virus, bugs, non-authorized human intervention, fraud or other causes beyond its control corrupt or affect the administration, security, fairness or proper conduct of the giveaway. In such a case, Pepper Gang may select the recipients from all eligible entries received prior to and/or after (if appropriate) the action taken by Pepper Gang. Pepper Gang reserves the right at its sole discretion to disqualify any individual who tampers or attempts to tamper with the entry process or the operation of the giveaway or website or violates these Terms & Conditions.

Pepper Gang has the right, in its sole discretion, to maintain the integrity of the giveaway, to void votes for any reason, including, but not limited to; multiple entries from the same user from different IP addresses; multiple entries from the same computer in excess of that allowed by giveaway rules; or the use of bots, macros or scripts or other technical means for entering.

Any attempt by an entrant to deliberately damage any web site or undermine the legitimate operation of the giveaway may be a violation of criminal and civil laws and should such an attempt be made, Pepper Gang reserves the right to seek damages from any such person to the fullest extent permitted by law.

By entering the giveaway you agree to receive email newsletters periodically from Pepper Gang. You can opt-out of receiving this communication at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the newsletter.

Limitation of Liability: By entering you agree to release and hold harmless Pepper Gang and its subsidiaries, affiliates, advertising and promotion agencies, partners, representatives, agents, successors, assigns, employees, officers and directors from any liability, illness, injury, death, loss, litigation, claim or damage that may occur, directly or indirectly, whether caused by negligence or not, from (i) such entrant’s participation in the giveaway and/or his/her acceptance, possession, use, or misuse of any prize or any portion thereof, (ii) technical failures of any kind, including but not limited to the malfunctioning of any computer, cable, network, hardware or software; (iii) the unavailability or inaccessibility of any transmissions or telephone or Internet service; (iv) unauthorized human intervention in any part of the entry process or the Promotion; (v) electronic or human error which may occur in the administration of the Promotion or the processing of entries.

Disputes: THIS GIVEAWAY IS GOVERNED BY THE LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND MASSACHUSETTS, WITHOUT RESPECT TO CONFLICT OF LAW DOCTRINES. As a condition of participating in this giveaway, participants agree that any and all disputes which cannot be resolved between the parties, and causes of action arising out of or connected with this giveaway, shall be resolved individually, without resort to any form of class action, exclusively before a court located in Massachusetts having jurisdiction. Further, in any such dispute, under no circumstances will participant be permitted to obtain awards for, and hereby waives all rights to claim punitive, incidental, or consequential damages, including reasonable attorneys’ fees, other than participant’s actual out-of-pocket expenses (i.e. costs associated with entering this giveaway), and participant further waives all rights to have damages multiplied or increased.

Privacy Policy:  Information submitted with an entry is subject to the Privacy Policy stated on the Pepper Gang Website.

Sponsor:  The Sponsor of the giveaway is Pepper Gang, 21 Union St. Boston, MA 02108, USA.

Fill out the form for your chance to win

Request Information For Your Next Highly Converting Website Below.

Request Your Hard Copy Of The MasterPlan for Google Ads eBook below.

Download The MasterPlan for Google Ads: Optimization and Opportunities eBook below.
Fill out the form and we will email you a copy.

Download The MasterPlan for Google Ads: Understanding Google Ads eBook below.
Fill out the form and we will email you a copy.

Download The MasterPlan for Google Ads: Thinking Outside the Box eBook below.
Fill out the form and we will email you a copy.

Download The MasterPlan for Google Ads: Nurturing Your Leads eBook below.
Fill out the form and we will email you a copy.